On AI Risk
“Right now, no lab has demonstrated much of a willingness to make any costly tradeoffs to get safety right (we get lots of safety committees, yes, but those are pretty meaningless). By default, we’ll probably stumble into the intelligence explosion and have gone through a few OOMs before people even realize what we’ve gotten into.”

Leopold Aschenbrenner · June 2024

Title and organization are as of the date said.

Primary source verifiedExpertise: AI alignment, AI forecasting, economicsLoss of controlRace dynamics

In context

We’re not on track for superdefense, for an airgapped cluster or any of that; I’m not sure we would even realize if a model self-exfiltrated. “Right now, no lab has demonstrated much of a willingness to make any costly tradeoffs to get safety right (we get lots of safety committees, yes, but those are pretty meaningless). By default, we’ll probably stumble into the intelligence explosion and have gone through a few OOMs before people even realize what we’ve gotten into.” We’re counting way too much on luck here.

The speaker’s own caveats

I’m incredibly bullish on the technical tractability of the superalignment problem.

Source

Cite this quote

Aschenbrenner, L. (2024, June). IIIc. Superalignment (Situational Awareness: The Decade Ahead). situational-awareness.ai. https://situational-awareness.ai/superalignment/

More from Leopold Aschenbrenner

“On the one end there are the doomers. They have been obsessing over AGI for many years; I give them a lot of credit for their prescience. But their thinking has become ossified, untethered from the empirical realities of deep learning, their proposals naive and unworkable, and they fail to engage with the very real authoritarian threat. Rabid claims of 99% odds of doom, calls to indefinitely pause AI—they are clearly not the way.”

Leopold Aschenbrenner · June 2024

Primary source verifiedPause
“We need to not screw it up. Recognizing the power of superintelligence also means recognizing its peril. There are very real safety risks; very real risks this all goes awry—whether it be because mankind uses the destructive power brought forth for our mutual annihilation, or because, yes, the alien species we’re summoning is one we cannot yet fully control. These are manageable—but improvising won’t cut it.”

Leopold Aschenbrenner · June 2024

Primary source verifiedExtinction riskLoss of control
“The AGI race has begun. We are building machines that can think and reason. By 2025/26, these machines will outpace many college graduates. By the end of the decade, they will be smarter than you or I; we will have superintelligence, in the true sense of the word. Along the way, national security forces not seen in half a century will be unleashed, and before long, The Project will be on. If we’re lucky, we’ll be in an all-out race with the CCP; if we’re unlucky, an all-out war.”

Leopold Aschenbrenner · June 2024

Primary source verifiedRace dynamicsTimelines

All 5 quotes by Leopold Aschenbrenner →

Others on the same topic

All quotes on loss of control →All quotes on race dynamics →

Report an error in this quote